One of the reasons why I insist on supporting all formula feeders - regardless of their reasons for not breastfeeding - is because we can never know someone's entire story. There are a myriad of complicated factors that play into our feeding decisions. The thing of it is, this isn't like any other food or health-related decision. Feeding a child from your breast is not like spending your food budget on healthy choices/organic brands, or quitting smoking, or limiting television, or exercising. It's not just a lifestyle choice. For some women, the act of nursing can be physically or emotionally painful - and frankly, that's not anyone's business but her own.
The woman who shares her story for today's FFF Friday wants to remain anonymous, for obvious reasons. But I hope she knows how incredibly brave she is - and how incredibly considerate to tell the truth about her decision in the hopes that it can aid the cause of supporting all women, breastfeeding, formula feeding, or anywhere in between.
The woman who shares her story for today's FFF Friday wants to remain anonymous, for obvious reasons. But I hope she knows how incredibly brave she is - and how incredibly considerate to tell the truth about her decision in the hopes that it can aid the cause of supporting all women, breastfeeding, formula feeding, or anywhere in between.
***
I was 14 when I was raped. Or maybe I was 15. I don’t really know…and to be honest that fact blows my mind, considering every other detail, like the way the forest smelt, the way my throat felt like it had a hot poker shoved down it and the way his eyes looked at me is embedded in my mind like little shards of glass. And wow how those shards have affected ever facet of my life since.
Truly it doesn’t matter though what age I was. What does matter was that it was someone I trusted. Not a family member or even a family friend but my own boyfriend who I had said no to repeatedly. The fact that I was confused about even calling it rape for many years is important to, because it dramatically shaped the way I felt about my body, who touched it and what I considered trust for over 10 years.
It affected my relationships with almost everyone, but the worst type was the Boyfriend type. Some were understanding and gentle when I suddenly stopped in the middle of being intimate with them, screwed myself up into a ball and sobbed my way through a couple of hours or when everything was going fine and they would touch me in a slightly different way and I would go stiff and unresponsive. Some were impatient and they didn’t stick around. Some like my poor ex husband suffered in silence for years until he was too scared to even touch me. Yeah, so it was a catalyst to ruining my marriage too… when we get down to it.
But this is a breastfeeding story, not a story about boyfriends.
I come from a place where breastfeeding rates are high. It’s the normal, responsible and practical thing to do. When friends and family did it, I thought it was the most natural thing in the world. When I thought about having babies in the future, I imagined holding that child in my arms and breastfeeding it.
I felt that way right up until about the 6 month mark of my first pregnancy. At first it started out with feelings of dread. A person, using my body again... even more than it already is during pregnancy. Relying on only me and that’s it – it scared me. It filled me with dread. But I told myself that was nothing, that I’m sure most people feel that way briefly if they would care to admit it. I countered it with positive thoughts and used a sort visualization technique to make my brain realise how wonderful it would be. I read up on breastfeeding benefits, how truly wonderful our bond would be. Etc etc.
Then I started waking at 2am in sweat after nightmares of a baby suckling blood from me. I tried the visualization stuff some more. Then I started having panic attacks during the day about it and I broke down in tears more than once about it, lets even go as far to say more than once a day about it. I tried talking to people who knew about my past about how I was feeling and they told me it would be fine, to just do it. Others had been through this before, they are fine.
Then, I started to hate the baby growing inside me. I truly and utterly hated it. Oh god, I resented it. I hated the fact I would be made to feed this thing from my body, FROM MY BREASTS. My most sensitive part of my body, that had had so much damage done to them in the past, the part of my body that my partner had to be careful about touching in case it made me fly into one of my sobbing fits. Someone FEEDING from me? I couldn’t cope.
I let the hate fester for a month or so. I felt I couldn’t discuss it with anyone because I got the ‘it will be fine’ talk or looked down at for feeling this way about my baby. . I couldn’t even discuss it with my partner or my best friend because I felt like such a failure. My mother doesn’t even know what had happened to me, neither did most of my family so there was no one to turn to there – not without opening a can of worms I didn’t want opened. I felt so ashamed, so guilty… but more than that I hated that creature for making me feel this way.
During the next visit with my midwife, I ended up breaking down. My blood pressure was sky high, I was obviously stressed beyond belief and she asked what was up. I told her I didn’t want the baby to come, that I really didn’t want to be a mother anymore. I was too scared to tell her why because I know how pro breastfeeding they all were but she got it out of me anyway. She looked at me carefully for a minute or two before taking my hand and saying the one thing that stuck with me since.
‘Then you will use formula, it’s a fine replacement and your baby will still thrive, be happy and healthy and more importantly, you will bond with him and love him more than anything you have ever loved before.’ She told me to let it go, to just look forward to holding the baby in my arms and the rest will happen.
So, that’s how it happened. My hospital notes got changed to ‘will artificial feed’ and we did. My partner gave my baby his first feed and the love on his face said how privileged he felt doing so. When I held my baby in my arms and gave him a bottle I felt so at peace. I could touch his little face and stare into his big bright blue eyes and tell him just how much I loved him and how he was the best thing to ever happen to me… and oh how I meant it.
***
If you'd like to share your story with the FFF audience, please email me at formulafeeders@gmail.com.









Major props to that midwife for actually listening and taking those feelings seriously! If only all health care professionals could be so understanding and reasonable.
ReplyDeleteThank you so much, anonymous author, for sharing such a deeply personal story. Congratulations on your son, and on being able to have the relationship with him you both deserve!
Your midwife sounded wonderful! The fact that she even realized what was going on without you saying it says a lot. I'm glad you had her for a doctor and thank you for sharing your story.
ReplyDeleteI never went through something traumatic like that, but I can relate to the scary dreams of breastfeeding. Shortly after I stopped I had a dream that my son lunged from someones arms, latched himself on, and literally went to suck the life out of me.
I was so terrified of him when I woke up that I quickly pushed him off onto the bed next to me and stared in horror. I couldn't hold him for the next 10 minutes. In the end I realized he would never care about being breastfed and seek out revenge like he did in the dream. It was such a scary dream though.
That one made me cry. Thank you for sharing.
ReplyDeleteYes, definitely THANK YOU for sharing. I know it probably wasn't easy.
ReplyDeleteThat's an awful story, but have you ever heard of counseling? Sheesh. I can't believe that your midwife, a health professional, didn't refer you for mental health services AND tell you the truth about the risks of artificial feeding to your baby. Healthcare fail.
ReplyDeleteTHANK YOU for posting your story. I am crying so hard I can barely type. It was like reading about myself. I, too, was raped by a boyfriend, and dreaded breastfeeding. (I am not 100% sure I consciously connected the two things.) I did not share this with anyone, and convinced myself that I should/could/would try to nurse, also visualizing the desired outcome.
ReplyDeleteIn my case, when the time came, my body took control of the situation and refused to produce any milk at all (the fruitless process of trying was humiliating and frustrating, but made the decision for me). My emotions were mixed: "broken" and devastated that I could not give my baby the "best", but also relieved (and guilty for feeling relieved).
In some ways, I feel that my body was sparing me from going through the agony that may have been to come, and instead has allowed me to enjoy a wonderfully loving bond with my baby - a gift I am thankful to be able to give.
---------------------------
Fortunately, my husband and family were supportive in light of my inability to breastfeed, and helped me move forward, but where I live is also a predominantly breastfeeding area; I found the lack of support resources for formula feeding (not just informational, but emotional) to be isolating. This is my first time on this site. Somehow I feel less alone. Thank you.
@Anonymous (the one before EL):
ReplyDeleteYours is the kind of comment that makes me rethink my "publish all comments" policy. Unbelievable. But perfect example of how lactofanatacism can override the typically female trait of compassion. So much for standing up for the sisterhood.
It's also pretty lame that you leave these comments anonymously. If you feel as strongly as you do, have the guts to put a name to your extremist POV.
Nursing is fantastic, but let's face it, even for those of us who do it successfully and love it, it is very, very taxing. I remember going through the six week growth spurt and feeling just
ReplyDeleteSO
USED!
It's true. I was nursing all day long. I was committed, but the depth of the committment really struck me on a visceral level at that point. So I completely empathize with this anonymous poster! If you already have major issues about that, nursing really could be rough. Because it's rough even without those issues. And yep, even if you feel very positively about it, it can be mentally and emotionally draining.
Huge hugs and applause to the author. Thank you for sharing this story. I just KNOW that you are helping others by speaking up and shedding light on this. How incredibly powerful! BRAVO!
ReplyDeleteAnd god bless that compassionate, reasonable midwife for lifting that weight from your shoulders.
Fearless FF, You are so right about Anonymous (after El). Appalling that after that incredibly moving story (thank you brave, beautiful author!) she has the gall to leave a cruel and thoughtless comment. People like that reflect horribly on their fellow lactivists.
ReplyDeleteI'm blown away by this powerful story. I relate in one small way. Breastfeeding was fine and uneventful for me with two babies. The third was fine until around 14 months. He starting biting. Eye eye eye, I have never felt so assaulted! I knew he didn't mean it, but the idea of feeding him felt insane, like returning to an abusive spouse for more! The second (and last) time he did it I was so mad (and luckily had someone helping that day) that I had to leave the house for awhile. In retrospect he was probably signally that it was a good time to wean -- and I did.
I was 17 when I was raped by a boyfriend. No, wait, 18. I can't remember. And no one knows, not my husband or my mom or my best friend, which is why I'm leaving this comment anonymously instead of signing in. I just wanted to thank you for sharing your story. This is EXACTLY why is makes me so angry when people say "all women should at least try to breastfeed." You never know what someone has been through and it would be cruel to expect someone to explain WHY she chose to not even try. So to that other anonymous, you get a big fat FUCK YOU and COMPASSION fail.
ReplyDeleteThank you to the author of this post for sharing so bravely. Thank you.
ReplyDeleteAnd I echo the comments of the others regarding the incredibly cruel anonymous comment. I don't understand how anyone could read that post and not respond with compassion. Let alone respond with such complete disrespect for someone's story.
Thank you for sharing your story, and I hope doing so help you feel just a little bit better, as sharing these stories sometimes does :-) I wish we as mothers did not have to feel so much guilt over this decision. Part of why I was in so much emotional pain after giving birth to my child was because I felt so much guilt about formula feeding, it just shouldn't be that way.
ReplyDeleteThis is such a difficult story to read; I can't imagine how tough it was to write. Thank you so much for sharing. And I'm so glad you found such a great midwife.
ReplyDeleteAnd as for anonymous, be reasonable: if mom isn't healthy, baby isn't healthy, and no amount of breast milk could have made up for the fact that breastfeeding would have probably driven her over the edge.
I'm afraid that the malicious anonymous comment above doesn't surprise me at all. Ever since my own dealings with the Boobjahadin I've associated words such as merciless with lactavism.
ReplyDeleteOriginal poster, thank you for sharing your horrific story so honestly. I am truly grateful on your behalf that your midwife was so decent, intelligent, and informed. Sadly, it doesn't always happen that way.
Thank you so much for posting your story. It is so brave and strong of you to tell us your experience. I connect with you because I also lived in a very pro-breastfeeding community and had to make an unpopular decision. Very much like how the 2nd anonymous poster. I think it is important because we need to not only look at medical reasons for not breastfeeding, but the emotional side too. I felt emotionally better when I formula fed and so did my daughter and husband. They could sense I was having a miserable time and I am really happy that you made a choice that worked for you and your baby from the very beginning. Kudos! My husband was also very happy to feed my daughter too so that was nice to hear your husband that connection too.
ReplyDeleteAs for the 2nd anonymous post. You are an outstanding example of all that is wrong with the fanatic lactivist community. You and many others I seen like you believe that a mother should breastfeed no matter what cost it is to her mental and physical health. Now how is this pro-mother and pro woman? It's not! Trust me these babies are smart and feel the mother's anxiety and discontent and that's not fair to them either.
@ Anonymous #2 - Yes, because the best thing for the baby is for her to continue the pregnancy with such high stress levels and blood pressure that she is at risk for an immediate end to the pregnancy and a completely UNnatural birth and delivery through (oh noes!) cesarian section (which, I assume, given your fanatical and borderline sadistic approach to "all things natural" you're against, right?) Or, if she does manage to go through a normal L&D process, for her to resent and dread nursing her baby so much that she neglects to hold, touch, or feed him. This is your mode of thought, neh? Well done.
ReplyDeleteBut you probably don't even take the time to read any of these other comments, do you? Nope. As demonstrated by your complete lack of response to any of the challenges on this particular page, you're more comfortable with a "hit-and-run" approach. Coward.
Forget the heart, (because we obviously can see that it's missing), do you even have a brain rolling around in that organic head of yours? Or do you just spout dogma like a parrot trained to speak on command? Think for yourself for once. Sheesh.
This is a really courageous story for your anonymous mom to tell! Very raw and emotional. Thank you for helping her share this... hugs to her and thanks to you for putting it out there. We DON'T know any individual's story. You are very right about that. We always have to remember that in the work we all do helping moms everywhere. I have had 2 similar patients and each one handled their unique trauma differently. Both had undergone a lot of therapy. One ended up nursing the other formula fed. That's really irrelevant though.. the point is that we as care providers or assistants to mom's get to know THAT MOTHER and respectfully assist her in fulfilling HER goals--> whatever they may be.
ReplyDeleteMore people need to read this. Thank you!
It is hard as a professional lactation supporter, I believe in informed choice, but there are extreme situations in which you have to ask yourself at what cost? Will any of the info I give change her mind? Should it? It's pretty obvious by this woman's description of her "breakdown" with the midwife, that the midwife made this call,and it was probably a difficult one. besides should this woman have given birth and felt differently about breastfeeding she always could have turned to her midwife and asked for help with breastfeeding. The more women I help the more I realize that this is not about me, my education, my convictions, it's about helping moms give their babies the best they can. That may include formula. An informed choice should include all information, what kind of support she has, past trauma, illnesses, what other responsibilities not just WHO guidelines. Then help her on her level. Thankyou for sharing.
ReplyDeleteThis is one of the reasons that my style of lactivism has nothing to do with judging moms for not breastfeeding and everything to do with breaking down the barriers that may make it difficult for women to breastfeed, which includes advocating against horrible crimes like sexual abuse and rape. I don't blame your guest poster at all for her decision. I blame the jerk who raped her and the society that teaches boys it is okay to force themselves on a girl/woman.
ReplyDeleteThanks for sharing your story.
ReplyDeleteProps to the midwife for supporting you like that. That's wonderful.
ReplyDeleteThank you for the [mostly] positive responses. It means alot, and helps with the healing process immensely, to know there are people out there who are supportive and understanding.
ReplyDeleteThank-you I thought I was the only one who went through this.
ReplyDelete